What is the best picture for a photo mosaic?
The picture your mosaic forms matters more than any other choice you make. A good one is recognisable from the first photo. A poor one stays muddy however many photos arrive.
How the picture is actually used
Your picture is cropped to a tall 4 by 5 shape and divided into a grid of 40 tiles across and 50 down, 2,000 in all. Each tile takes one colour from the part of the picture it covers. People's photos are placed where their own colours fit best, and each is lightly tinted toward its tile's colour.
So the mosaic can only show what survives at 40 by 50. Every rule below follows from that one fact.
The ten-second test
Open the photo on your phone and hold it at arm's length, or shrink it until it is the size of a postage stamp. If you can still tell at once who or what it is, it will make a good mosaic. If you have to look closely, choose another.
What works
One subject, close up. A head-and-shoulders portrait gives a face several hundred tiles to work with. Two people work if their heads are close together.
Clear light and dark. Faces lit from a window or photographed outdoors on a bright, cloudy day have shape. Direct flash flattens a face into one pale area with little in it.
A plain background that differs from the subject: dark hair against a pale wall, a light shirt against a hedge. The outline is what people recognise first.
Bold graphics. A logo, a crest, a large numeral or a single thick letter often reads more clearly than any photograph, because it is already made of simple shapes.
What does not
Group photos. Ten people across the frame leaves each person four tiles wide and each face narrower still, which is not enough to recognise anyone.
Fine detail: small lettering, thin lines, patterned clothing, lace, distant buildings. Anything narrower than a tile disappears.
Busy backgrounds such as a crowd, a bookshelf or foliage. They turn into scattered colour that competes with the subject.
Very dark pictures. Tiles in dark areas are tinted dark, so the photos placed there are harder to see when someone zooms in. A night-time or candlelit photo hides a large share of the contributions.
Cropping and quality
The crop to 4 by 5 is automatic and is centred on the most prominent part of the photo. That is usually right for a portrait. For a wide photo it may not choose what you would, so crop it yourself first: upright, with the subject filling most of the frame and a little space above the head.
Sharpness and file size matter much less than you might expect, since the picture is only read as a coarse grid. An old, small or slightly soft photo is fine if it passes the ten-second test. A print photographed with a phone is fine too: lay it flat near a window, with no flash and no frame glass.
If you get it wrong
You can change the picture later from your owner page. The photos people have added stay, and the tiles rearrange to form the new picture. It is worth trying two or three candidates in the first few minutes, before you share the link.
Questions
Does a black and white photo work?
Yes. The mosaic depends on light and dark areas more than on colour. The tiles are tinted toward the picture's greys, so the result looks muted.
Can I use a landscape-shaped photo?
Every mosaic here is upright, 4 wide by 5 tall, so a landscape photo loses its sides. Crop it to an upright shape yourself so that you choose what is kept.
Can the picture be a logo or a drawing?
Yes, and these often give the clearest result. Use a version with thick shapes and a solid background, and leave off any small text.
Does the picture need to be high resolution?
No. It is read at 40 by 50 colours. The sharpness of the printed file comes from the tiles, each of which is a contributor's photo, not from the main picture.
Free to make and share. No account for you or for the people who add photos.